Medical professional typing on a laptop

Medical negligence

Ian Paterson: what you need to know

The NHS has paid out nearly £18 million, of which £9.5 million was damages, following claims from nearly 800 patients of Paterson.

28 April 2017

The story

From 1993 to 2012, it is thought that more than 700 patients underwent extensive, life-changing operations by breast surgeon, Ian Paterson, for no medically justifiable reason.

Mr Paterson, 59, worked at hospitals run by the Heart of England NHS Trust and Spire Healthcare.

The procedures occurred at Heart of England NHS Trust and privately-run Spire Healthcare hospitals in the West Midlands.

Concerns about his work first surfaced in 2003, but it was not until 2012 that he was excluded from the trust where he worked.

An independent review by Verita found that there were a number of missed opportunities in the private sector between December 2007 and August 2011 to have monitored Mr Paterson’s behaviour and practices and take action.


In 2012, the surgeon was suspended by the General Medical Council in 2012.

More than 550 patients were recalled to hospital to have their cases reviewed.

Mr Paterson, of Castle Mill Lane, Ashley, Altrincham, faces one charge of causing grievous bodily harm and 20 of wounding with intent.

Mr Paterson stands accused of carrying out invasive breast surgery on women with suspected breast cancer when a simple biopsy might have been sufficient. He is also alleged to have performed lumpectomies and lymph node removal on vulnerable patients when it was not needed

He is also accused of using an unrecognised procedure, known as a cleavage sparing mastectomy, which involves leaving behind some potentially cancerous tissue for cosmetic reasons. These led to many patients needing further surgery to remove cancerous tissue.

In 2013, Spire Healthcare announced its own independent review into how it responded to concerns regarding Mr Paterson at Spire Parkway and Spire Little Aston, and breast care services at Solihull Hospital

Spire’s Management were informed of concerns regarding Mr Paterson’s surgical technique in December 2007, yet the Spire did not start their own investigations into Mr Paterson’s practices at their Hospitals until 2011. This was too little, too late for many of Mr Paterson’s private patients who underwent unnecessary surgeries between 2008 and 2011.

The NHS has paid out nearly £18 million, of which £9.5 million was damages, following claims from nearly 800 patients of Paterson.


Ian Paterson has been convicted of 17 counts of wounding with intent after carrying out a series of "completely unnecessary" operations as well as three counts of unlawful wounding.

The medical negligence solicitors at Slater and Gordon specialise in claims against the NHS, GPs, private doctors and hospitals arising out of negligent medical treatment and acts on behalf of injured victims.

Contact us

If you’ve been affected and need legal advice, please contact one of our medical negligence specialists.

All information was correct at the time of publication.

Find out more from our experts
Surgeons passing tools during surgery
Medical negligence
Victims of surgeon Ian Paterson awarded £37 million

Victims of rogue surgeon Ian Paterson have been awarded £37 million in compensation. Find out about the case and the settlement our incredible team secured.

Gendered Health Inequalities
Medical negligence for women’s health

Often, when women approach healthcare professionals with concerns about their health, they’re downplayed or ignored, which can have life-changing implications. In fact, 52% of women feel like a “number” when seeking help from their GP. We have provided the tools you need to advocate for yourself.

Man in wheelchair with woman drinking coffee
Medical negligence
Cauda equina syndrome claims
If there were delays in diagnosing and treating your cauda equina syndrome, Slater and Gordon’s specialist legal experts can help get the compensation you deserve.
teenage boy with mother at table
Medical negligence
What is the Tavistock clinic scandal?
The recent news that the NHS Tavistock Centre is facing mass legal action has caused grave concern amongst many. Here, our medical negligence experts discuss the news, and the legal implications this might have.
Search our website
Sorry, we have no results to show
Please try a different search term.
Oops, something went wrong
Please try typing in your search again.
Back to top